We manufacture aluminium windows, so you can reasonably expect this to end with “buy aluminium”. It mostly does — but not always, and the exception matters more than the rule. There is one situation where timber is the right answer and we will tell you to go elsewhere for it.
Here is the comparison we actually give people on the phone.
The short version
| Timber sash | Aluminium sash | |
|---|---|---|
| Repainting | Every 5–8 years, plus access | Never |
| Rot and swelling | Cills and bottom rails, eventually | Does not absorb water |
| Sticking in winter | Common once paint fails | No |
| Typical U-value | 2.0–2.6 W/m²K (double glazed) | 1.0–1.6 W/m²K |
| Single glazed original | around 4.8 W/m²K | — |
| Cleaning upstairs | Ladder or cradle | Tilt in, from inside the room |
| Security certification | Rare | PAS 24:2022 on the Smart VS400 |
| Slimmest sightlines | Wider — timber needs bulk for strength | Slimmer — aluminium is stronger per mm |
| Listed building, like-for-like | Yes | Usually refused |
| Conservation area | Yes | Often accepted |
| Expected life | Indefinite — if you keep painting it | Decades, unmaintained |
The maintenance question, with real numbers
This is the whole argument, so it is worth doing properly rather than waving at “low maintenance”.
A painted timber sash window needs repainting roughly every five years, sooner on south and west elevations where UV does the most damage. That is not just paint. On a typical three-storey Victorian terrace it is scaffold or a tower, a decorator for several days, and preparation — because by year five the previous coat is flaking and has to come back to sound timber before anything new goes on.
Skip two cycles and the sequence is predictable, and we see it constantly:
- Paint fails on the bottom rail and the cill first — that is where water sits.
- Bare timber absorbs moisture and swells.
- The sash sticks. Someone forces it.
- The cords go, or the sash splits at a joint.
- Water now sits inside the joint. Rot starts.
- You are into repair, and repair on a sash window is joinery, not filler.

None of that happens to aluminium. It does not absorb water, so it cannot swell, split or rot. The finish is a powder coat applied to a Qualicoat-certified process — the colour is bonded to the metal under heat, not painted onto the surface waiting to peel. There is nothing to sand and nothing to repaint. Maintenance is washing the frames and keeping the drainage channels clear.
Over a 30-year period, a timber sash gets painted five or six times. An aluminium sash gets painted zero times. That is the real difference, and it dwarfs the gap in purchase price.
Where timber genuinely wins
Two places, and we want to be straight about both.
1. Listed buildings requiring like-for-like replacement
If your consent requires genuine like-for-like replacement — same material, same construction, often same glazing — that is specialist joinery, not aluminium. No aluminium system will satisfy it, ours included. We will tell you this on the phone rather than quote you for something that gets refused. Find a heritage joinery firm; it is a different trade and they are good at it.
Note the distinction that trips people up: listed building and conservation area are not the same thing. A listed building has statutory protection on the fabric itself. A conservation area protects the character of the area — and that is a test aluminium very often passes, because the test is what the street looks like, not what the window is made of.
2. You want real timber, because you want real timber
Some people want wood. The grain, the weight, the way it feels to lift. That is a legitimate reason and no comparison table beats it. We are not going to argue you out of it.
Will aluminium sash windows pass in a conservation area?
Often, yes — but it depends entirely on the system, and this is where most of the bad advice lives.
A conservation officer is not checking the material. They are checking proportion and joint detail. And the giveaway on most aluminium sash windows is the corner.
A real timber sash is assembled with the rail running through and the stile butting into it, leaving a visible horizontal joint at each corner. Its bottom rail is noticeably deeper than the rest of the sash, because historically it carried the weight and the sash lift. Those two details are what a trained eye looks for.
Most aluminium sash windows mitre the corner at 45°, because that is the fastest way to build an aluminium frame. The result can be the right colour, the right size, carry the right glazing bars — and still be refused, because the corner says “aluminium” from thirty feet away.

This is exactly why the Smart VS600 exists. It is built with square-cut sash joints and a deep bottom rail specifically to reproduce the timber detail. It is the system we specify on period terraces, on Georgian and Victorian elevations, and on any application that has already had one refusal.
If authenticity is not the constraint — a new build, an extension, a converted commercial unit, a contemporary house that wants the sash proportion without the pastiche — the newer Smart VS400 is the better window. Mitred and crimped corners, and it is tested to PAS 24:2022 as standard, which no timber sash will offer you.

Energy efficiency: the gap is bigger than people expect
An original single-glazed timber sash sits at roughly 4.8 W/m²K. That is close to having a hole in the wall. A modern double-glazed timber sash improves it to around 2.0–2.6 W/m²K, which is respectable.
Aluminium goes further, because a thermally broken aluminium profile can be engineered in ways timber cannot. The VS600 reaches 1.6 W/m²K. The VS400 reaches 1.4 W/m²K with a 1.0 centre-pane unit, and 1.0 W/m²K with a 0.5 centre pane.
That matters most on the buildings where you cannot do anything else. On a period property where the walls are solid brick and the roof is already lined, the windows are the only remaining place to find the improvement. Going from 4.8 to 1.0 on every window in the house is a different building.
The VS400 also takes sealed units from 24mm up to 36mm. A 36mm pocket accommodates triple glazing, or an acoustic laminate — which on a main road, a flight path or a city-centre conversion is the entire specification. A 28mm system simply cannot fit the glass.
What about uPVC?
Worth addressing, because it is usually the third quote.
uPVC sash windows are cheaper and genuinely low-maintenance. Their problem is proportion. uPVC is not structurally strong, so profiles have to be bulky to carry the glass — which means thick frames, thick sashes, and a window that reads as plastic on a period elevation no matter what colour you order or what woodgrain foil is applied.
Aluminium is stronger per millimetre than both timber and uPVC, so the frames are slimmer and the glass area larger. On a building where the window proportion is the architecture, that is the difference between a restoration and a replacement.
uPVC also has no meaningful conservation-area case. If a planning condition is involved, it is very rarely the answer.
Cost: what actually drives the number
We are not going to print a price per window, because anyone who does is quoting a window you do not want. What we will do is tell you what moves the number:
- Size. Both Smart systems go to 1600mm wide × 2800mm high, at 50kg per sash. Anything larger is coupled units, which costs more.
- Glass. Standard double glazing, triple glazing, or acoustic laminate — a real spread. This is where the 36mm pocket on the VS400 earns or costs you money.
- Glazing bars. Georgian bars add fabrication time. Six-over-six costs more than one-over-one.
- Sash horns. Optional on both, and usually worth it on a Victorian elevation.
- Colour. The four standard RALs are the quickest. Bespoke matching adds lead time.
- Supply or supply and install. We do both, nationwide.
The number that matters is not the purchase price, it is the 30-year cost. Five or six repaints with access, versus none, closes a lot of gaps.
So which should you buy?
Timber, if your building is listed and the consent demands like-for-like, or if you simply want wood.
The Smart VS600, if the building needs to read as timber — conservation area, period terrace, or a planning officer who has used the word “authentic”. Square-cut joints, deep bottom rail, optional horns.
The Smart VS400, if you need PAS 24:2022 security, a U-value down to 1.0 W/m²K, glazing up to 36mm, or a clean contemporary frame line.
We fabricate both in our own factory in Slough and install nationwide, so we have no commercial reason to push you toward either one. Send us the elevation and, if there is one, the planning reference — we will tell you which will get through, and we will tell you if the answer is neither.
Request a quote for aluminium sash windows →
More detail on both systems, including full specifications and a side-by-side comparison table, is on our aluminium sash windows page.